The Ultimate Sesame Street Birthday Party

For Sophie’s second birthday last April we had a huge Sesame Street party. I spent HOURS planning and creating things for this party. I have promised myself not to go so overboard this year considering the fact that my due date is only about a month after her birthday.

Let me share with you how it all came together!

Sesame Street Character Pom-Poms

No Sesame Street party would be complete without our favorite characters! The character pom poms were the perfect decoration to hang from the trees in the back yard. So colorful and fun! I saw the pom poms for sale on Etsy but decided I could make my own. The pom-poms themselves were a piece of cake to make using this tutorial but attaching the faces was a different story.

I drew the eyes, noses and mouths using a Sesame Street coloring book as a guide, and cut them from construction paper. I originally tried to mount the faces on the tips of the tissue paper but that didn’t work well. So I attached the face pieces to the ends of pipe cleaners with tape and wrapped the opposite end around the center of the pom-pom. That took the weight off the ends of the tissue paper but caused the front of the pom-pom to droop so Elmo & friends appeared to be looking at the floor.

On to plan C! When I hung these with fishing line on the day of the party I ran an extra piece of fishing line under the mouth of each character to help support the extra weight in the front. In other words, I hung each pom pom using two pieces of fishing line — one from the center and one to support the front.

The Arrival

Signs that I made on Picmonkey directed guests to our backyard for the party.

A sea of Sesame Street character footprints greeted the guests as they entered our backyard. Luckily, we had a beautiful sunny day!

Sesame Street Party Activities

To keep party guests busy, we had a variety of Sesame Street party themed activity centers which included:

Cooking with Cookie Monster

(***How adorable is this kitchen???? You can read about it in this post.)

Oscar’s Trash Toss with a genuine aluminum trash can.

This post contains affiliate links. As a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, I earn a small commission from qualifying purchases linked from my site.

Bubbles with Big Bird

Bert & Ernie’s Chalk Station

On a side note…Sophie got this Melissa & Doug art easel as a birthday gift and we LOVE it. It has a dry erase board, chalk board and paper in the middle which can be pulled over either side for drawing and painting.

Elmo’s Crayon Station & Grover’s Play-Doh Station

Pin the Nose on Elmo with magnet noses, using the other side of the easel Sophie got for her birthday. My dad had a piece of aluminum cut to fit the front of it that Sophie can use for magnets. We simply clip it on with some binder clips and take it off when she wants to draw.

Count with The Count

The ideas for the bubble station, trash toss and counting game came from Annie’s Eats. I came up with the others myself.

How to Make a Personalized Sesame Street Sign

The Sesame Street party would not have been complete without Sophie’s name on a Sesame Street sign. I drew and cut the sign from green foam board and cut the yellow border around the sign from yellow poster board; then laid it on top of the green foam. I used Interstate Bold Compressed font for the letters. I just printed really big versions of the letters which I traced on to and cut out of white poster board. Then I glued everything down with rubber cement.

The playset Sophie received for her birthday looked great decorated with the sign, which now resides over the window in her playroom.

Sesame Street Cupcakes

We got inspiration from Annie’s Eats for the cupcakes, which included Elmo, Big Bird, Oscar, Cookie Monster and Grover. We used a cut marshmallow lined with a red sugar sheet and covered in yellow icing to make Big Bird’s beak, and candy eye balls, jelly beans and black sugar sheets to create the character’s facial features. Each cupcake had a colored cupcake liner that coordinated with the color of the character, with the exception of Oscar who got a silver foil liner to represent his trash can. (Thank you to my husband Robbie for that clever idea!)

The cupcake tower was actually just an inexpensive Wilton cupcake tower that I embellished with 1″ wide red and white polka dot ribbon.

We learned our lesson the hard way that you should not put the candy eye balls on the cupcakes until right before the party because they will absorb the color of the icing. We put the eyeballs on the night before the party and woke up the next morning to find Elmo with bloodshot red eyes. Robbie had to make a mad dash to the store for replacements. That wasn’t the only disaster…read on to the cake section.

Elmo Cake

Since Sophie has an egg allergy, we made the cake ourselves, using the following chocolate cake recipe:

1 1/2 cups flour
1/3 cup cocoa powder
1 tsp. baking soda
1/2 tsp. salt
1 cup sugar
1/2 vegetable oil
1 cup cold water
2 tsp. vanilla extract
2 tsp. vinegar

Preheat oven to 350. Mix all dry ingredients together. Mix all wet ingredients in separate bowl except the vinegar. Add wet ingredients to dry & stir until all dry ingredients are mixed. Add vinegar quickly & stir in. Pour into cake pan and immediately put pan in oven and bake for 25 to 30 min.

I have to give most of the credit to Robbie for the cake decorating. He took charge of the cake preparation since I was engrossed with decorating cupcakes. He used a wet knife to to smooth out the yellow icing to look like fondant, and molded Elmo out of Rice Krispy treats held together with tooth picks. As with the cupcakes, we made Elmo’s face from candy eye balls , a jelly bean nose and mouth cut from a black sugar sheet.

We were up until 3am the night before the party decorating the cake and cupcakes! In addition to the discolored eyes we were met with the following morning, Elmo had fallen apart and was lying in a pile on top of the cake. The original Elmo was larger and we can only figure that his head and arms were just too heavy for the toothpicks to support.

The eye balls were easy enough to replace, but the cake? I thought it was a goner for sure. Once again…Robbie to the rescue. Before I knew it he’d whipped up another batch of Rice Krispy treats and red icing and made a smaller Elmo that survived until party time! He would do anything for his little girl!

It was insanity around out house that morning, to say the least! But most importantly, Sophie thought the cake was yummy!

Sesame Street Party Favors

Guests received two favors: A handmade Sesame Street coloring book with pack of crayons and a chocolate covered Elmo Oreo.

I made the coloring books from construction paper, twine and coloring pages I printed from HERE. I printed two pages per sheet so they were roughly half the size of 8.5 x 11 paper. Then used a paper cutter to cut the sheet in half and hole punched twice along the left side of each sheet. Then I folded a piece of construction paper in half, hole punched it in the same place as the coloring sheets, placed the coloring pages inside the folded construction paper and used twine to tie it all together. I made a cover using Sesame Street clip art and used rubber cement to glue the cover on the construction paper.

To make the Elmo Oreos, I inserted lollipop sticks into the center of Oreos and then in melted red candy melts. Double Stuffed Oreos work best since there is more cream to hold the stick.

Here is a handy tip for you: Before dipping, careful open the Oreo, gently press the stick into the cream, and place a little bit of melted chocolate over the stick to hold it in place before replacing the top of the Oreo. Then dip, and place on wax or parchment paper to dry. We tried just poking the stick up into the cream without opening the Oreo, and half the time the Oreo would break.

We made the face from candy eye balls, an orange jelly bean nose and a mouth cut from a black sugar sheet. Gently press these items on immediately after dipping the Oreo in chocolate.

We covered the Oreos in clear plastic sandwich bags and attached a “Thank you for celebrating with me!” tag with twine. We used a gift wrapped shirt box with holes to make the stand for them.

The Elmo Oreos received Sophie’s stamp of approval.

Sesame Street Party Invitation (and an old friend)

I purchased the invitation for our Sesame Street party on Etsy and had to search for awhile before finding one with Grover. Sophie loves Grover. Poor Grover got the shaft when Elmo came along, and he’s not as easy to come by as the other characters. She used to call him “Super Yo-Yo.” The “Super” part obviously came from Super Grover but the Yo-Yo? Who knows! She was just learning to talk.

And speaking of Super Yo-Yo. He was one of my favorites as a kid too. Here we are sitting at a wooden table set made by my dad. We still have this table and Sophie uses it when she visits her granddaddy.

On a side note….This little guy was stashed away in the attic for the last couple decades. I decided to pass him along to Sophie, but unfortunately he had that awful attic smell. So I washed him, and 2 days later (after multiple tumbles in the dryer) he still couldn’t hold his head up because it was still so wet. I thought he was a goner. But Robbie suggested cutting him open, removing the stuffing and replacing it will fresh DRY stuffing.

What did I have to lose? He was destined for the trash at this point. So we told Sophie that Super Yo-Yo was going to the hospital for an operation, but was expected to make a full recovery. We took the seam ripper to him and would you believe that his head was full of this nasty stuffing that looked like carpet padding. We threw that all away, replaced it will fresh polyfill and sewed him back up.

Now he’s as good as new! Well…maybe a little more matted that he used to be after being in the dryer so long but he’s still kicking and enjoying new adventures with Sophie!

I couldn’t be happier with how our Sesame Street party turned out. It was a lot of work, but seeing Sophie’s excited face made it all worth it!

P.S. Then we went to Disney World the following month and she hasn’t been interested in Sesame Street since!

And now I bet I’ve got you wondering…what is our party theme for this year???